The tide may be turning in the closely watched legal battle between Ripple Labs and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. A recent ruling from the Second Circuit Court of Appeals could significantly weaken the SEC’s arguments and strengthen Ripple’s defense.
The case in question, SEC v. Govil, involved allegations of fraudulent offerings of securities by Aron Govil through his company Cemtrex. The SEC sought disgorgement, a court order requiring the return of improperly obtained funds.
However, the Second Circuit ruled that the SEC could not seek disgorgement unless investors could prove they suffered actual financial losses. This “no harm, no foul” approach undermines the SEC’s strategy and offers Ripple a potential lifeline.
Ripple cheers court victory in similar case
Ripple Chief Legal Officer Stuart Alderoty wasted no time celebrating the Govil decision. He highlighted the SEC’s string of recent defeats and highlighted the ruling’s relevance to the company’s ongoing lawsuit.
“The SEC keeps losing,” Alderoty said. “The Second Circuit Court of Appeals…held that if a buyer suffers no financial loss, the SEC is not entitled to restitution from the seller.”
The SEC keeps losing. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals declined to reconsider its ruling in Govil, which held that if a buyer suffers no financial loss, the SEC is not entitled to restitution from the seller. https://t.co/AOEHcyiajo pic.twitter.com/TPCbmAcAmY
–Stuart Alderoty (@s_alderoty) April 11, 2024
The SEC is seeking a hefty $2 billion restitution and penalties from Ripple, accusing the company of selling unregistered securities in the form of XRP tokens. The Govil decision raises questions about the validity of the SEC’s disgorgement requests, which could save the company a significant amount of money if the court adopts similar reasoning.
Ripple prepares to counter SEC’s $2 billion demand
With the Govil decision as a potential shield, Ripple is preparing to respond to the SEC’s demands. April 22 marks a critical date as she prepares her official response to the $2 billion penalty. Legal experts expect a strong defense from Ripple, potentially citing Govil precedent to challenge the disgorgement aspect of the SEC’s case.
Bitcoin is now trading at $67.454. Chart: TradingView
The Ripple Effect of Crypto Legal Battle
The outcome of this legal battle will have considerable consequences for the cryptocurrency sector. A Ripple victory could set a precedent that makes it more difficult for the SEC to continue disgorging future crypto-related cases. Conversely, a victory for the SEC would strengthen its regulatory authority in the area of digital assets.
May 6 looms as another potential turning point in the Ripple-SEC saga. While details remain secret, the date could mark the filing of key motions or the scheduling of crucial court hearings.
The legal battle between Ripple and the SEC is far from over. While the Govil decision adds a new level of complexity, the coming weeks and months promise to be a period of intense legal wrangling as both sides fight for a decisive victory.
Featured image from Pexels, chart from TradingView
